Econlib Resources
Subscribe to EconTalk
Audio
To subscribe in iTunes, click this button  or drag this icon  into your iTunes Podcasts
playlist
Other podcast players (Yahoo Podcasts, Podnova, etc.): Audio RSS feed or Feedburner audio (XML) To subscribe to Annual Archives of podcasts by year: Text and Audio
Text RSS
feed or Feedburner text (XML. Includes audio)
Email (Weekly email with latest text and audio. No spam.) More
FAQ
(Instructions and more options)
|
|
||||||||
|
Blogging software: Powered by Movable Type 4.2.1.
Sound engineer: Rich Goyette Music from Cleared up Sunset, by Yasuhiro Tsuchiya / unplug Picture of Russ Roberts courtesy of the author. All opinions expressed on EconTalk or in the podcasts reflect those of the authors or individual commenters, and do not necessarily represent the views or positions of the Library of Economics and Liberty (Econlib) website or its owner, Liberty Fund, Inc. 
The cuneiform inscription in the Liberty Fund logo is the
earliest-known written appearance of the word
"freedom" (amagi), or "liberty." It
is taken from a clay document written about 2300 B.C. in the Sumerian city-state of Lagash.
|
||||||||
Gotta say Russ, that was pretty weak. You obviously don't like psychiatry, but that has little to nothing to do with economics. You don't like this study and you don't like their methods. OK, but why devote an entire podcast to your distaste? Your closing remarks were particularly blind. In the description of the boy that was "out of control" you missed one of the tell tale signs, the parents thought they would have to call the police. Puberty is rough on kids and parents, but it does not normally involve the cops. This podcast reminds me a lot of some of your lectures, you seem to forget that your opinion about something isn't always interesting, but it doesn't stop you from rambling about it. At least I didn't have to pay tuition in addition to wasting my time to hear this...
Hearing you rail against psychiatry by using this dubious study is very much akin to me dismissing economics based on Samualson's reports on Soviet Russia. Academics perpetuate this kind of fraud all the time, they create some sort of "ism" out of nowhere and spend their lives arguing for it so that they can be published. I could argue that Samualson's work cost us billions in cold war spending because an economist managed to quantify how far behind the reds we were....
You can be quite good when you stick to economics, but you have a habit of thinking that everything that is dear to Russell Roberts is economics when it is not. I would seriously recommend taking this podcast down. It sticks out like a sore thumb, has little to do with economics, and tarnishes what has otherwise been a fine series. Stick to interviews, stick to the economics, and you produce great stuff...
Isaac
Well said,i applaud your blog, mental health consumers are the least capable of self advocacy,my doctors made me take zyprexa for 4 years which was ineffective for my symptoms.I now have a victims support page against Eli Lilly for it's Zyprexa product causing my diabetes.--Daniel Haszard www.zyprexa-victims.com
I must have missed the "rail[ing] against psychiatry" in general. It seems to me that the Russ confined his criticism pretty much to this study with the exception of some pretty questionable regulation.
On the podcast itself, I thought it was interesting but not as much as some of the others, perhaps.